Spring Break
OP-ED: Giving Hitler a chance to speak
by Daniel Wolfe
Op-Ed | 10/2/07
Posted online at 9:49 PM EST on 10/1/07
/ Last updated at 2:49 AM EST on 10/1/07
Shame on Columbia. According to Dean of International and Public Affairs John Coatsworth, "If Hitler were in the United States and wanted a platform from which to speak, he would have plenty of platforms to speak in the United States … If he were willing to engage in debate and a discussion to be challenged by Columbia students and faculty, we would certainly invite him." Well, that makes me feel good about the state of our country, when our best universities are eager and willing to debate a murderous maniacal dictator who put a brutal and sudden end to European Jewry. I suppose it would have been important before we make any moral judgments-God forbid!-to hear Hitler's side of the story. After all, perhaps some Jews wronged him, and he had strong reasons for his just plans.
Perhaps the debate would have sounded like this:
Coatsworth: "Well Mr. Hitler, thank you for coming. I know you are very busy over there murdering so many Jews and Poles. I'm glad you could take out time for us. Now, let me ask you, why do you feel like you need to kill so many innocent people? You know, that doesn't fly in this country. You better give a good explanation."
Hitler: "Well, the Jews are simply an inferior race, and we need to create a perfect Aryan race that dominates the world."
Coatsworth: "Okay. I guess then we will simply have to agree to disagree. But that is precisely what makes this country so great. We allow people with all views to come up and give their opinions, even if they are genocidal maniacs. Thanks for coming."
Sadly, in America today, our universities are losing touch with reality. We are so caught up in an elitist bubble that we are blinded by our own sincerity. Morality is no longer a relevant concept. In fact, in universities we are taught that there is no such thing as morality. Thus, our top universities have very few qualms about inviting oppressive dictators to our best campuses.
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has incited genocide against the Jewish state, has oppressed members of the Baha'i faith, has put to death homosexuals-which explains why there are "no homosexuals in Iran"-and has aided our enemies in Iraq. Yet our own self-righteousness dictates to us that he should be able to express his ridiculous views in our schools. Frankly, I think this is absurd. There needs to be a line on academic debate drawn, and inviting Ahmadinejad assuredly crosses that line.
Perhaps the debate would have sounded like this:
Coatsworth: "Well Mr. Hitler, thank you for coming. I know you are very busy over there murdering so many Jews and Poles. I'm glad you could take out time for us. Now, let me ask you, why do you feel like you need to kill so many innocent people? You know, that doesn't fly in this country. You better give a good explanation."
Hitler: "Well, the Jews are simply an inferior race, and we need to create a perfect Aryan race that dominates the world."
Coatsworth: "Okay. I guess then we will simply have to agree to disagree. But that is precisely what makes this country so great. We allow people with all views to come up and give their opinions, even if they are genocidal maniacs. Thanks for coming."
Sadly, in America today, our universities are losing touch with reality. We are so caught up in an elitist bubble that we are blinded by our own sincerity. Morality is no longer a relevant concept. In fact, in universities we are taught that there is no such thing as morality. Thus, our top universities have very few qualms about inviting oppressive dictators to our best campuses.
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has incited genocide against the Jewish state, has oppressed members of the Baha'i faith, has put to death homosexuals-which explains why there are "no homosexuals in Iran"-and has aided our enemies in Iraq. Yet our own self-righteousness dictates to us that he should be able to express his ridiculous views in our schools. Frankly, I think this is absurd. There needs to be a line on academic debate drawn, and inviting Ahmadinejad assuredly crosses that line.
Be the first to comment on this story